Five Common Mistakes Florida Homeowners’ Associations Make
By Maggie Nolan, Esq.
Homeowners’ associations throughout the state of Florida have a number of responsibilities to adhere to, and sometimes it can be difficult to keep track of the procedures and deadlines that accompany those responsibilities. This article considers some of the most common mistakes made by a board of directors when managing an association.
No. 1, Failing to Provide Proper Notice of HOA Board Meetings
One of the most common mistakes a board of directors can make is failing to comply with the statutory requirements when providing notice of an upcoming board meeting.
Chapter 720, or the Homeowners’ Association Act (“HOA Act”), expressly states that a board of directors shall either comply with the notice requirements set forth in its bylaws or, if silent, shall comply with the notice requirements within Section 720.303(2)(c).
There are two things to keep in mind when providing proper notice. First, there are the contents of the notice. The written notice must identify the agenda of items to be discussed at the upcoming board meeting. Second, there is the method of delivering the notice to the owners. The notice must be posted in a conspicuous place within the community at least 48 hours before the meeting, except in cases of an emergency. If not posted, the notice may be mailed or delivered to each owner at least 7 days before the meeting, except in the case of an emergency. In the alternative, the notice may be electronically transmitted to an owner if he or she has previously consented to such method of delivery in writing.
However, the general notice requirements change when either special assessments or a change in the association’s rules are the topic of a board meeting. In those cases, written notice of the meeting must be mailed, delivered or electronically transmitted to the owners and posted conspicuously or broadcast on a closed-circuit television not less than 14 days before the meeting. It is important for the board of directors of an association to be aware of this difference in providing notice.
No. 2, Selective Enforcement of HOA Rules and Regulations
The board of directors of an HOA must be mindful to avoid selective enforcement of its rules and regulations. “Selective enforcement” refers to when an association enforces its rules inconsistently across its members. Applying the rules unfairly not only invites disputes among members, but it also creates legal concerns for the association and its board of directors. Examples of board actions that may appear as selective enforcement include:
- Pursuing violations against some delinquent members while sparing others;
- Applying the same violation differently among delinquent members; and
- Ignoring or overlooking certain members’ violations due to internal bias.
It is important for the board to recognize how selective enforcement may occur and prevent it from happening in its community. The board should ensure that the rules and regulations are being applied evenly among the members.
No. 3, Imposing HOA Fines Without Following Statutory Procedures
The Florida Statutes allow the board of directors to impose reasonable fines and suspensions for violations of the association’s rules established in the governing documents. The statutes concerning the imposition of fines and suspensions provide a board with clear procedures to follow when implementing such penalties.
A fine cannot exceed $100.00 per violation against a unit owner or any owner’s tenant, agent or invitee for the failure of a member or its occupant, licensee or invitee to comply with the governing documents. A fine may be imposed each day the violation remains, so long as notice and an opportunity for a hearing were provided to the owner and the fine does not exceed $1,000.00 in the aggregate, or as otherwise provided in the governing documents. A fine of less than $1,000.00 may not become a lien on the property.
Additionally, an association may suspend a unit owner’s right to use the common areas and facilities for failure to follow the association’s bylaws and rules. The suspension can also apply to the owner’s tenant, guest or invitee. The suspension must be for a reasonable amount of time.
Nevertheless, prior to either a fine or suspension being imposed on a unit owner or their occupant, the board of directors must provide at least 14 days’ written notice to the owner and any tenant, licensee or invitee of the particular fine or suspension to be imposed. The notice shall also provide the owner with an opportunity for a hearing before a committee of at least three members. The committee cannot consist of officers, directors or employees of the association, nor the spouse, parent, child, brother or sister of an officer, director or employee. The hearing must be held within 90 days after the notice is issued to the owner.
If the committee, by majority vote, does not approve of the fine or suspension, then such fine or suspension cannot be imposed. The committee must provide written notice to the unit owner of the committee’s findings within 7 days after the hearing. The board must ensure that its committee follows such procedures and delivers the findings to either the mailing address or email address listed in the association’s records for the owner.
No. 4, Failure to Maintain or Provide Access to HOA Official Records
A homeowners’ association is required by Section 720.303(4) to maintain the following records for at least 7 years, unless the governing documents require a longer period of time. Such items shall be considered official records of the association:
- Any plans, specifications, permits and warranties related to improvements constructed on the common areas or other association property;
- The bylaws and each amendment thereto;
- The articles of incorporation and each amendment thereto;
- The declaration of covenants and each amendment thereto;
- The current rules and regulations;
- The minutes of all meetings of the board of directors and of the members;
- A current roster of all members and their designated mailing addresses and parcel identifications;
- The association’s insurance policies;
- All contracts to which the association is a party, including bids received by the association for work to be performed that must be kept for one year;
- Financial and accounting records of the association;
- Disclosure summary described in Section 720.401(1), Fla. Stat.;
- Ballots, sign-in sheets, voting proxies and all other papers and electronic records relating to voting by parcel owners that are to be maintained for one year after the date of the vote;
- All affirmative acknowledgements made pursuant to Section 720.3085(3)(c)3; and
- All other written records related to the operation of the association.
Not only does the board of directors have the obligation to maintain these records for at least 7 years, but it is also responsible for making them available to a unit owner for inspection or copying within 10 business days upon a written request. The board may impose a fee for copies of official records, generally amounting to 25 cents per page. However, if the board requires a third-party vendor to make copies of the records, then it may charge the actual cost of copying, as supported by an invoice from the vendor.
A unit owner may use a smartphone, tablet or other device capable of photocopying or scanning to make an electronic copy of the official record requested. In such a case, the board may not charge a fee for copying.
Florida law allows a board of directors to adopt reasonable rules monitoring the frequency, time, location, notice, records to be inspected and manner of inspections. However, Florida law does not permit a board to demand that a unit owner (i) have a proper purpose for requesting to inspect the records; (ii) state a reason for the inspection; or (iii) limit a unit owner’s right to inspect to less than one 8-hour business day.
No. 5, Neglecting the HOA’s Governing Documents
Finally, the board of directors must remember to revisit the governing documents when confronted with any issue or undertaking. When faced with an issue or task, the first step the board should take is to reference its governing documents to see if such issue or task is addressed. The governing documents are the board’s guidelines and, in most cases, go into further detail than the procedures outlined in Chapter 720. While the board must still be sure to comply with Chapter 720, it should also always refer to its own rules set forth in the governing documents when faced with an issue or task.
In summary, the board of directors of an HOA holds a great amount of power and authority when managing a community. With such power and authority come important obligations. By adhering to the procedural and substantive law set forth in both the Florida Statutes and the association’s governing documents, the board can work to minimize the likelihood of any of the mistakes discussed in this article.
If your HOA board is seeking further information or guidance, please feel free to contact me at maggie.nolan@henlaw.com to schedule a consultation.
This article is for informational purposes only and does not provide legal advice. Please do not act or refrain from acting based on anything you read here. Please review our full disclaimer for more information. Relying on the information provided in this article or communicating with Henderson, Franklin, Starnes & Holt, P.A. through our website does not create an attorney/client relationship. Legal counsel and analysis will not be provided to non-clients. If you are interested in retaining our attorneys, please contact us here.
